World opinion is divided on the importance of having a free press, according to a poll conducted for the BBC World Service.
Of those interviewed, 56% thought that freedom of the press was very important to ensure a free society.
But 40% said it was more important to maintain social harmony and peace, even if it meant curbing the press's freedom to report news truthfully.
A total of 11,344 citizens in Brazil, Egypt, Germany, Great Britain, India, Kenya, Mexico,
Nigeria, Russia, Singapore, South Africa, the United Arab Emirates, the United States, and
Venezuela were interviewed face-to-face or by telephone between October 1 and November
21, 2007. Polling was conducted for the BBC World Service by the international polling firms
GlobeScan and Synovate and their research partners in each country.
56% of people in the 14 countries polled think the press and media in their country is free to
report the news accurately without bias. Only 19% say there is little or no media freedom in
their country.
Private and publicly funded news organisations receive similar ratings from the public when
it comes to reporting the news honestly and accurately. 39% of people across all countries
say publicly funded news agencies are doing a good job, while 43% say the same for private
news organisations.
However, in some countries the poll shows concern over the ownership of private media.
Strong majorities in Brazil (80%), Mexico (76%), USA (74%), and Great Britain (71%) believe
that the concentration of media ownership in fewer hands is a concern because owners’
political views emerge in reporting.
Of the countries where press freedom is most highly valued, Western developed countries
are more critical of how honestly and accurately the news is reported, including Germany
(28% average rating for good performance of public and private media), Great Britain (29%),
and the USA (29%) whereas Venezuela (44%), South Africa (49%), Nigeria (58%), and
Kenya (61%) rate the media performance more positively. (See diagram below).
In countries where social stability is more highly valued, those surveyed in India (61% good
performance) and the UAE (52%) believe the news is being reported honestly, contrasting
with a more negative view of press performance in Russia (27%), Mexico (28%), Brazil
(31%) and Singapore (37%).
India
Although Indians are not strong advocates of media freedom and are generally satisfied with
the accuracy of news reporting in their country, they are in favour of having a say in news
reporting decisions.
India is one of only three countries where people who believe stability is more important than
press freedom outnumber those who believe freedom is more important. Forty-eight percent
of Indians (versus 40% globally) put stability first, while 41 percent (56% globally) put
freedom first. A further 11 percent did not answer this question. In terms of its ability to report
the news accurately and without bias, the Indian media is perceived as freer than that of
almost any other nation in the survey. Seventy-two percent of Indians give a high freedom
rating, compared with 56 percent worldwide. Only 10 percent give a low freedom rating,
compared with 19 percent globally. Indians are more positive about the accuracy and
honesty of government or publicly-funded news reporting than any other country surveyed.
Fifty-seven percent of Indians give a “good” performance rating to public news organisations,
compared with 39 percent globally. Private, for-profit news organisations are viewed more
favourably, with 64 percent rating their performance “good” (versus 43% globally), although
this is slightly less positive than the response in Africa. Fifty-seven percent of Indians agree
that growing consolidation of private media ownership is a major issue “because you often
see owners’ political views emerge in the news”, while only 30 percent agree with the
opposing view that “media owners do not interfere with the news content” (14% did not
answer). Fifty-five percent think “it is important that people like me have a say in what gets
reported in the news”, while 33 percent think “decisions as to which stories get reported in
the news are best left to news organisations”, with a further 12 percent unable to answer.